Should I pull the plug on my mother?

Show all answers

Post your answer

busymomkaren	what would she want? has she ever talked to you about this? Imagine in your mind sitting at the kitchen table talking to her about this and what she would say. Then, do that. Just remember, no mom wants to be a burden to her child. No woman wants to be in agony. In addition to the physical pain, the pain of knowing you are in this situation is hard on her. It is equally hard to know that you are killing her. But the question is, are you killing her? Or is it just the shell she used to inhabit? Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

Southern Girl	O M G you poor child. My heart goes out to you. Does your mom have a WILL or signed paper saying she would rather die than live in pain? Very tough for you to live with should you decide to pull the plug. I would talk to a Pastor NOW!!! You need guidance sweetie. This will effect YOUR life forever. I'll say a prayer for you. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

sweetness #1	Oh honey, I cannot imagine how torn you must be. No body can make this decision but you. I want to wish you the best of luck....All you can really do is to pray.......your answer should come to you thru prayer. Good luck and God bless you and your mom Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

我比你聪明	What were your mother's wishes? Did she ever sign a living will or discuss any end of life issues with you. If not maybe she discussed it with some other relative. The important thing is that her wishes should be carried out. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

Live Life the fun way!	oh hunney dont ask anyone that nobody can tell you the right answer im so sorry for you i will keep you in my prayers im sorry i cant help you but i think the answer is down deep in the bottem of your heart!!! Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

girl	i know this is a VERY hard decision but for your mom u shoudl pull the plug. dont listen to the doctor its not killing ur mom. would u rather your mom die peacefuly and be able to say goodbye or spend a few weeks of torture, just lieing in pain not being able to say or do anything and die a slow painful death!? just think i know it is the matter o a ew weeks but think about your mom more than yourself! the women will be in pain not able to do anything, sitting there for you to see her!!! she is probly in enough pain already, a person isnt a painting. instead of making her suffer let her die naturally instead of being an artificial human being. just make her last moments worth living for. just for explamlary* purposes.. you have a choice o dieing painlesly with your family now or live just a few WEEKS not months WEEKS were talking a handful of days, in pain and torture and die a painful death that your amily may not be there to hold your hand in your inal hour but instead a nurse, looking down at you, u no just waiting or you to die so she can clean up the room, sure she'll cry but its her job, and her job is over. a life is SUPPOSED to be heaven on earth so why would you want your last momments to be HELL? Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

papafrita_picante	Number 1 her life is God's so ask him first. Number 2, I had to do it to my dad and it was the hardest thing ever. I still get upset at myself to this day, even though deep down I did what he would have wanted. Number 3, Ummm, obvious answer, never make someone you love suffer.... Number 3, ask God. The thing I regret the most is not begging God to heal my dad like I should have...God can do anything and He says that if we ask Him and have COMPLETE faith He'll do anything we ask of Him. Now don't underestimate the word COMPLETE... It doesn't come to us all at once. At least ask Him to help you through this time. He loves you and wants to be near you. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

lady JG	You don't say if your mother is aware of what is happening or not. Also, do you have any siblings that you could talk with regarding such an important decision. Has your Mother ever expressed her desire regarding the end of life issues? It is not killing her if you remove mechanical support, it is simply allowing nature to take it's course. The good Lord gave the medical people knowledge to help prolong life but it should be a life with dignity. Compassion is just as important. As others have suggested, you should seek out the support of your clergy person (if you have one) or other relatives or friends. Unlike some others here, I think that you are not asking for us (yahoo answer) to provide you with the actual answer but rather are trying to use this forum as a sounding board and to ask for advice No matter what your final decision is it will be difficult to say that final goodbye. My prayers are with you Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

cute.stuff_8391	ethically it's not up to you to take the life of another human being - even though that power may have been granted to you by our medical and governmental system. God decides when and who he takes. i know this sounds like preaching and i'm going to try and do as little as possible so that no one gets on my back about it... but....... pray to God that he will take her right away so that you don't have to kill her and she won't be suffering. i know i'm not in your shoes right now and i don't understand fully but that's what you should do... that's all i'm going to say........... if you choose to pull the plug and not listen to me about God then on judgment day you will be confronted about it........... good luck with that btw..... pray to God to take her as soon as possible... - - and believe - - and be patient too, ask and you shall receive - - but it's like asking for things here on earth, it's not always instant. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

DTott	I'm so sorry to hear about this. It is such a difficult and painful decision and I hope there is someone there with you that you can talk to and to help you make this decision so you don't have to decide on your own. It is so hard to think about letting your mother go. Please listen to what the doctors are saying and follow their guidance. Talk to your mother and tell her how much you love her and that you're making the best decision for her. Please have a friend or family member go to talk to the doctor with you as I'm sure it is such a difficult time for you and you may not be able to absorb everything the doctors are telling you. I wish you the best. Please take your time and after listening to the doctors, spend some time with your mom and then make the decision that you feel is best for you. You mom would understand and will always be with you.. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

"Speedy"	Well, technically speaking, by letting her go, you aren't killing her. The cancer is. Don't think of it as killing her. She is suffering by being kept alive. She really isn't living. The machines are doing the work for her, but if she is suffering when she's awake and constantly asleep, then is she really alive. This is a tough question to answer, and you just have to make the determination for yourself. You have to do what you feel is right. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

Exotic Pink	oh wow. i am so sorry you are going through this tough time. do you have another loved one that you can talk to about this? Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

metch	this really is not a question you should be asking random people on yahoo answers. i understand that you're under a lot of pressure. there are different consequences for each action. this is something you need to think about. what is best for your mother... for you... what's God's will? you should pray. if you're not religious, maybe now's a time to consider... Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

Asha	First, I am so sorry that you have to go through this. Especially during the holiday season. I understand how you feel. I had to make the same decision for my father. Second, you wouldn't be killing your mom. Never think that no matter what you decide. What you need to ask yourself is this. Is my having my mother around, in constant pain, worth it knowing that I caused that pain. Has she people she wants to see before she dies. Is she able to communicate her wishes? When she is awake do you have meaningful conversations? I can't make the decision for you, but I can tell you what my decision was. My father had Alzheimer's. I was Daddy's little girl, too. But I decided not to give my Dad a feeding tube because I knew he didn't want to stay around wearing diapers, being cleaned up by others, not recognizing anyone. My Dad was a proud man always dressed to the nines. He would have been horrified knowing what happened to him later in life. Thankfully, we found a great nursing home that treated his body with the respect it deserved for carrying such a wonderful man through this life. I can tell you that no matter what you decide, it will be painful and you will have doubts. What would you want done if you were in the same situation? Has your mom ever spoken about it before. My mom did so again, thankfully, I didn't need to decide. She wanted to be a full code no matter what. It didn't help when the time came, but at least I felt some comfort knowing that I had done what Mom wanted. My husband and I both have discussed our wishes at length. If there is no hope for recovery, neither of us want to be kept alive. Let life progress naturally. But if your mother is awake and aware, you need to realize that she may need to say goodbye to someone or give you some final words. My thoughts and prayers are with you at this very sad and difficult time. Good journeys and bright blessings to you, your Mom, and your family. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

bickie	Umm...is there a way that you could ask her? Does she have a living will? I wouldn't want to put my mom through that kind of pain....It's time to let her go even though it's hard.... Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

Billy H	Wow... I can't imagine the pain of indecision here. I don't really have an answer, but only can say that my prayers are with you. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

mystic_majic_lil_lady	dear its a hard thing to do but it has to be done.... if i were in your moms shoes i wouldn't want to suffer. i would hope that my family would let me go and say good bye while i was still alive... then i would know before i was gone that you all would be OK. its OK to be sad for your mom but its better to be happy that shes not hurting any more... and shes in a better place. go to her doctor and ask for a preacher to come to her room and pray for her and your family and say your good byes and let her go... your not killing her your saving her from weeks of pain and suffering... god bless you and tell your mom i said hello and god be with her on her journey to heaven... be at peace cheers jo Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

Fran	You need to check and see if your mom has a living will. If so, her wishes will be listed there. If not, if your mother can talk you need to check and see what she wants to do. You may think of Hospice services. They can handle the pain control. Decisions like this are always hard and one you have to live with. with the decision you make. God bless you...... Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

montefraya	I'm so sorry you are faced with this decision! I too had to make that decision four years ago when my sweet mother was near death. It is sadder to me to put them through the mechanics of living by artificial means than to let them go peacefully. It only prolongs the inevitable. You would not be killing your mom. Hospice explained to me that mom's system was not strong enough to even handle a glass of water and that it would probably cause lots of problems as her kidneys and other body systems were shutting down. My heart goes out to you, it is not an easy decision to make. If it helps you, I made the decision to let her go peacefully. I kissed her and told her I loved her. I know I will see her again someday. God bless! Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

murse dan	This is something that you should discuss with your mother if she is still able to communicate. I know it is hard to make that decision, but at the same time, you must figure out what is more important, that she is alive, but has a poor quality of life, or you let her die and she is at peace. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

LM	It gets to the point where you have to ask yourself a few things: is it really your mother under all those tubes? Or is your real mom the one that stayed up with you when you were sick and such. I'm in favor of euthanasia so this is just my opinion. Let me share something. My grandmother has full dementia now. She gained 30 pounds from not being able to move. All she does is eat and stare. No talking or laughter. I can't even think of her as my grandmother anymore. My real one is in my memories, baking cakes and playing tag. It gets to a point where you have to ask yourself how much suffering do you want to go through. Both you and her. You can keep her around for as long as her disease lets you but what's the point if she's not the same person anymore. Think of your mom. What would she do in the situation? What would your last memory of her be? Peacefully drifting off or in pain? I'm not pro death or anything like that, but considering the circumstances.... My condolences either way. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

imdubdabass	if you are religious consult your priest Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

Someday	Sorry if this affends you but honestly you should pray about it. God knows whats best for her and you. She could pull through or she could die on her own no one knows execept Him! I really don't want to affend you, but it's what i'd do! Good luck for both of you. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

jkbond17	You didn't say if she is coherent when she is awake. If she had a Power of Attorney for health care decisions, you would already know what her wish would be. When asked (ahead of time) whether to resuscitate or not, most people reply "Save my life, but don't prolong it." You are going to have to "let her go" sooner or later any how. Try to base your decision on what she would probably want for herself. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

elizabeth_ashley44	Pull the plug. You wouldn't be killing her. By keeping her alive through the machines, you're just prolonging her inevitable death. Say your goodbyes, find a good support system for yourself, and let your mother go in peace. I wish you the best as you go through this very difficult time. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

alicefay4u	Whatever you decide, you will not be happy with your decision. You will feel guilty, but, you must accept the fact that it is not your fault. I cannot tell you what to do, but if it was my decision i would not pull the plug. I believe your mom can hear you and think and maybe she needs the time with the Lord. Is she saved? That would be a large factor to me. Talk to your pastor or priest a close friend. Cry a lot let it out I understand, I have been on this path. Pray and listen to your heart. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

patd_lover	Life is a sacred gift from God. All things happen for a reason. What she needs most is your unconditional love. have faith in God. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

DH	You poor thing! What a dilema you are in! First off, I want to say, I don't want to be in your shoes. I really feel for you and I'm sorry you are being forced to make a decision like this. There's never a good time to make these kinds of decisions, and we are never fully prepared to make them. With that said, Here is my answer: Pray. Even if you are not religious, pray. Just a few words. Ask for God's help. Also, ask your mom. If she has any capability to speak or communicate, you need to discuss this with her. If she is unable to communicate (she's on life support, in a coma) then you have some heavy thinking to do. Does she have a DNR (do no resusitate) order? If so, she's already made the decision for you. If not, you should put yourself in her position. Think about how you would feel if you were going through what she is going through. Would you rather live in pain for a few more weeks just so your loved ones could spend just a little more time with you, or would you rather die a possibly slow, maybe painful or painless, but peaceful death? Me personally, I wouldn't want to be in pain. Also, consult the rest of your family. If you have someone in the family you can discuss this with, it will probably be easier for you to decide. Here's a little story about one of my coworkers who died this past summer. She was only about 34 years old, has an adorable son and a great husband. She was driving home from work late at night one night and accidentally hit a semi. She ended up in the hospital for a week, with severe brain swelling, and with everyone on edge not knowing if she would survive (she was breathing without a ventilator, but no brain activity) and be fine, or be a vegetable the rest of her life. After a few days in the hospital, and after numerous tests, and the swelling in her brain refusing to go down (in fact, the swelling moved down her spinal cord and got worse), her family finally decided to take her off the life support that she was on and off all week. They had planed to donate her organs after her death. She finally died a few days later. While preparing to harvest her organs for transplant, the doctors found she had cancer. Not just any type of cancer, but the type that you don't know you have until it's too late. This strain of cancer starts in your organs and basically eats away at everything, causing a slow and extremely painful death, with no chance of a cure. The doctors estimated that she would've only had about another 2 years left to her life anyways. Long story short, even though she died from injuries that were the result of a major accident, it was a quick and painless death, as opposed to a long drawn out, painful death. I wish you luck with your decision. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

LittleBarb	This is a PRIME example why EVERY PERSON should make their wishes known IN WRITING to family, their doctors and whomever else is responsible for their health care... I already HAVE a DNR on file because I am terminally ill and when my time comes, I do NOT want to be "kept alive" by artificial means... especially since to ME that really isn't LIFE... it's existance.... A dog or a horse breaks its leg, it is humainly put to sleep.... why should our PARENTS and GRANDPARENTS have to suffer .... My father had a DNR on file, and when he got near death, I watched as he suffered TERRIBLE PAIN as they SCRAPED the inside of his lungs every 20 minutes because his EX WIFE (my former step mother) MADE them put him on a respirator.... I came in and raised holy hell because I KNEW about the DNR order...I being his BLOOD NEXT OF KIN ....but it is MORE difficult to get a person OFF life support once they are put ON IT..... ESPECIALLY when there is no writtnen words by the patient. For some reason, the doctors took my father off ALL PAIN MEDS so he would be LUCID and asked HIM if he wanted the DNR.... he shook his head YES and he had to be slowly weined off the respirator---that took 6 more DAYS that he suffered NEEDLESSLY!!!! It is NOT killing if you decide to pull the plug---it is ENDING YOUR MOTHER'S SUFFERING... and THAT is the greatest gift you could EVER GIVE HER... death with DIGNITY!!!! Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

shiprepairwoman	Good luck whatever you decide. Since they haven't put her on the machine doing nothing would be the quickest for her. If she has a DNR respect it. If she can make her own choices let her. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No

Bingo's Mommy	Wow, that's a lot for you to deal with. The decision is yours and yours alone -- unless you have siblings. Take as long as you can to sort things out and try to come to the decision that you can live with and consider what she would want. Seek the support and counsel of some close friends and relatives. Was this answer helpful to you? Yes / No